Movies
4:08 pm
Sat June 29, 2013

Rescued, Hitchcock's Silent Films Flicker Anew

Originally published on Sat June 29, 2013 6:07 pm

Alfred Hitchcock's early silent films have resurfaced in what's being called the single biggest restoration project in the history of the British Film Institute, and now "The Hitchcock 9" are touring the U.S. this summer.

Hitchcock is best known for his Hollywood suspense films of the post-war era, like Psycho and Vertigo. But the director was born in England and began his directing career there during the silent era. In fact, he loved both seeing and making silent films.

"Silent pictures are the pure motion picture form," he told Francois Truffaut in a famous 1962 interview for the book that the French critic and director wrote on Hitchcock.

A Silent Celebration

Silent films set the tone for Hitchcock's whole career, says Bryony Dixon, the British Film Institute's curator for silent film.

"He thought it gave you more scope as a filmmaker," she says. "It was a more elegant way of making films. It obliged you to tell your story in pictures, which is what the cinema is all about, rather than falling back on dialogue. And he continued to make films, even in the sound era, that had that quality. He could tell stories with pictures incredibly well."

The film institute's restoration of The Hitchcock 9 has Queen Elizabeth's jubilee to thank. Dixon says all of the big cultural institutions tried to do something to celebrate.

"And we chose our big icon, you know," Dixon says. "Drama has Shakespeare. Literature has Dickens. We have Hitchcock."

Only one of Hitchcock's silent films is still missing — amazing, because most silent films have been lost. And like so many surviving silent films, Hitchcock's nine remaining films needed restoration desperately.

So the institute scoured the world, finding copies forgotten in archives, adding and rearranging bits and pieces. Restorers discovered a whopping 20 minutes to add to the director's first film, The Pleasure Garden, made in 1925. Like many of the silent Hitchcock films, it's not a thriller; it's a steamy showgirl drama.

Music To Fill The Silence

The film institute also commissioned new scores for some of the films. Stephen Horne, a veteran of live silent film performances, composed a lyrical score that he'll play live at some showings of The Hitchcock 9 in the U.S.

Horne says he wasn't intimidated by following in the footsteps of Hitchcock's famous musical collaborator on Psycho and Vertigo, Bernard Herrmann, because they were doing different things.

"There have been cases," Horne says, "where sound film composers have scored silent films and it hasn't been effective — and vice versa — because the technique is not as transferable as you might think."

The British Film Institute commissioned different kinds of music for The Hitchcock 9, in order to reach different kinds of audiences. Popular British rapper and saxophonist Soweto Kinch wrote and recorded a jazzy, syncopated score for Hitchcock's boxing drama The Ring. Yet the Colorado-based Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra takes a different approach to the same scene.

What Would Hitchcock Hear?

The Monto Alto group is engaged in its own kind of restoration project. The music of the orchestra, which will play at several stops of the American tour, represents a much earlier jazz tradition. The musicians find and play only the music that was available to movie accompanists in the silent era.

Movies were often accompanied by different pieces of music depending on the theater and the musicians. Few silent films had composed scores; most had lists of suggestions for music to be played. But the orchestra's Rodney Sauer could not find any record of what might have been played in picture palaces and in small neighborhood theaters for Hitchcock's films.

"To be honest, I think Hitchcock would have hated it," Sauer says of the selections made by musicians at theaters. "He thought music was extremely important. He always wanted the perfect pieces to be played to his films. You know, in the silent era he was creating these films and sending them out, and God knows what would be played to them. It might be nothing."

So Sauer and the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra picked what they thought seemed appropriate for the time and the films.

If you want to see — and hear — The Hitchcock 9, you'll have to do it in a theater. There are no plans — and no financing — for a DVD set.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

JACKI LYDEN, HOST:

Whew. Let's stick with British film for a moment and news about the biggest single restoration project in the history of the British Film Institute. Nine films by Alfred Hitchcock are now touring the U.S., but these are not his well-known thrillers like "Vertigo" and "Psycho." These are his earliest silent films. Pat Dowell has more.

PAT DOWELL, BYLINE: Alfred Hitchcock loved silent films. Here's what he told French director Francois Truffaut and his translator in a famous 1962 interview for his book on Hitchcock.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ALFRED HITCHCOCK: Silent pictures are the pure motion picture form.

DOWELL: Silent films set the tone for Hitchcock's whole career, says the British Film Institute's curator for silent film Bryony Dixon.

BRYONY DIXON: He thought it gave you more scope as a filmmaker. It was a more elegant way of making films. And it obliged you to tell your story in pictures, which is what the cinema is all about, rather than falling back on dialogue. And he continued to make films, even in the sound era, that had that quality. He could tell stories with pictures incredibly well.

DOWELL: The BFI's restoration of "The Hitchcock 9" has Queen Elizabeth's jubilee to thank. Dixon says all of the big cultural institutions trying to do something to celebrate.

DIXON: We chose, of course, our big icon, you know? Drama has Shakespeare. Literature has Dickens. We have Hitchcock.

DOWELL: Like so many silent films, Hitchcock's needed restoration desperately. The BFI scoured the world, finding copies forgotten in archives, adding and rearranging bits and pieces. One film remains lost, but restorers discovered a whopping 20 minutes to add to the director's first film, "The Pleasure Garden." Like several of the silent Hitchcock films, it's not a thriller. It's a steamy showgirl melodrama.

The BFI decided to commission new scores for some of the films, including the tragic romance set on the Isle of Man "The Manxman."

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DOWELL: The score's composer, Stephen Horne, who play his music live at many showings of "The Hitchcock 9" in this country, is a veteran of silent film performances. He wasn't intimidated by following in the footsteps of Hitchcock's famous musical collaborator on "Psycho" and "Vertigo," Bernard Herrmann, because they were doing different things.

STEPHEN HORNE: There have been cases where sound film composers have scored silent films and it hasn't been effective, and vice versa, because the technique is as not as transferable as you might think.

DOWELL: Horne says in talkies, music can serve as counterpoint to dialogue and sound effects. For Hitchcock's boxing drama "The Ring," the BFI commissioned British rapper Soweto Kinch to punctuate a scene in which a woman betrays her lover.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DOWELL: The Colorado-based Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra took a different approach to the same scene.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DOWELL: The group is engaged in its own kind of restoration project. It finds and plays only the music that was available to movie accompanists in the silent era. But the group's Rodney Sauer couldn't find any record of what might have been played in picture palaces and in small neighborhood theaters for the films of Alfred Hitchcock.

RODNEY SAUER: He thought music was extremely important. He always wanted the perfect pieces to be played to his films. You know, in the silent era, he was creating these films and sending them out, and God knows what would be played to them. You know, it might be nothing. To be honest, I think Hitchcock would have hated it.

DOWELL: So Sauer and the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra picked what they thought seemed appropriate for the time and the films.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DOWELL: If you want to see and hear "The Hitchcock 9," you'll have to do it in a theater. There are no plans and no financing for a DVD set.

For NPR News, this is Pat Dowell. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related program: